Some of the links below are affiliate links, so we may receive a commission, at no cost to you, if you make a purchase through a link. Check our Disclosure in the Privacy Policy for more info.
Old School Butterscotch Tart Recipe
Delicious old school butterscotch tart! A mouth-watering dessert popular in many primary schools. This retro dessert is so easy to make and the taste is just so good.

Who remembers this old school butterscotch tart? I certainly do! A smooth, creamy and sweet butterscotch filling that sits on top of a buttery shortcrust pastry bed.
It has the perfect balance of buttery and caramel flavours and it’s the perfect recipe for nostalgia and comfort. I have so many memories enjoying this tart during school dinners, and now, memories of me enjoying it at home too!
The flavours are amazing, and the texture is delightful… Doesn’t this all sound amazing? If the answer is yes (and let’s be real, it should be), then get ready to make this butterscotch tart from scratch…

What Is Butterscotch Tart?
Butterscotch tart is a traditional British school dinners dessert, it consists of a pastry base filled with a smooth and indulgent butterscotch filling.
The filling is typically made of brown sugar, butter and flour mixed with milk, but some recipes vary and include eggs and cream.
It tastes like a caramelised brown butter caramel that’s thick, smooth and rich. Traditionally in British schools, this school dinner pudding would be served with custard or whipped cream.
It goes by a variety of different names all that vary slightly in ingredients or in how it’s made. A few names I know this recipe as is butterscotch tart, caramel tart and also as gypsy tart.
Watch How To Make It
Why You’ll Like This Recipe
- The perfect dessert for all occasions
- Use readymade shortcrust pastry to make this dessert fast
- No fancy ingredients just basic cupboard fillers
- The perfect dessert for people with a sweet tooth
- An easy butterscotch tart recipe with a tasty filling
Shop-Bought Pastry Or Homemade Pastry?
I like to make my own homemade pastry but if I’m in a rush shop-bought pastry works just as well. The main difference is that shop-bought pastry will not be as buttery or as sweet as homemade shortcrust.